20 of Our Meatiest, Beefiest, and Most Savory Mushroom Recipes (2024)

Get ready to celebrate the meatiest vegetable there is because October 15th is National Mushroom Day. No matter which type of mushrooms you like — White Button mushrooms, Cremini, Portobellos, Oyster, Shiitake, and Trumpet mushrooms – they are all delicious.

When you want that meaty, umami flavor, mushrooms are the way to go. That’s why you find them in so many plant-based dishes. Their flavor is rich, earthy, and meaty, especially Cremini or Portobello mushrooms. Their texture, as well as their taste, lets mushroomsreplace meatin any recipe.

You probably know that mushrooms are healthy. They are low in sodium, low in calories, and filling, so they can help us maintain our weight. Mushrooms arefiber-richand can help regulate cholesterol. They are a good source of protein, potassium, B vitamins, and theonly plant sourceof vitamin D.

Mushrooms are also versatile. You can eat them for breakfast, lunch, and dinner. They can be cooked whole, sliced, or stuffed. Whether they are sautéed, roasted, baked, grilled, stuffed, or eaten raw, mushrooms are amazing. If you need ideas, see these30 Cool Vegan Recipes Made With Mushrooms, 21 Ways to Enjoy All Kinds of Mushrooms,10 Delicious Ways to Cook With Mushrooms,and Celebrate Mushrooms With These 20 Savory Recipes. Then try these 20 recipes for our meatiest, beefiest, and most savory mushroom dishes.

1. Pesto Portobello Sandwich With Spicy Sauce

There are many tasty and convenient vegan bacon alternatives you can buy at the store. However, nothing beats the satisfaction (and rich flavor) of making your own homemade bacon. In this Pesto Portobello Sandwich With Spicy Sauce, Portobello mushrooms are sliced, marinated in a savory tamari-maple mixture, and topped with a sprinkle of smoked paprika and pepper. The result is a deliciously smoky and umami bacon that is perfect for vegan BLTs, topping salads, and stacking on burgers.

2. Spinach Crepes With Creamy Mushrooms

These Spinach Crepes With Creamy Mushrooms are such a delicious meal – light, fluffy and tender crepes lovingly wrapped around the most amazing creamy mushroom mix, flavored with punchy hints of garlic, shallot, and thyme. These spinach crepes are so easy to make, 15 minutes in total (after soaking the chickpeas the day before), and miraculously don’t fall apart or stick to the pan despite the absence of eggs and oil. You will fall in deep mad love with this creamy, crepey mushroomy creation. Definitely one to put on your to-do list this week!

3. Filipino Mushroom Chicharon

Chicharon is a well-loved Filipino snack made of fried pork rinds (similar to the Mexican chicharron). It’s usually enjoyed as food paired with beer known as “pulutan“. Filipinos love to dip chicharon in condiments such as spiced vinegar. It’s also a popular topping on Filipino noodle dishes. This vegan Mushroom Chicharon is made from white fungus, a mushroom that can be found at most any Asian supermarket. It is simple to make and fun to eat as crunchy snack or garnish on your favorite dish.

4. Mushroom Fajitas With Chimichurri

While you can make fajitas in a variety of ways depending on your preferences, this recipe for vegan Mushroom Fajitas With Chimichurri is a surefire winner! With marinated Portobellos, homemade taco seasoning and effortless chimichurri sauce, these fajitas are a savory bomb of flavor that will taste like they took all day to make. Top with a drizzle of vegan sour cream and a dollop of guacamole for additional deliciousness.

5. Mushroom and Vegetable Protein Sausages

If you are craving sausages but aren’t happy with the supermarket options, then this tasty vegan Mushroom and Vegetable Protein Sausage recipe is perfect for you. Made from Portobello mushrooms and textured vegetable protein, these sausages are packed with flavor. You can put it on the grill for a barbecue, have it at home on a lazy Sunday with mashed potatoes and gravy, as a hot dog, or just on its own. And you can even freeze them to save time during the week!

6. Mushroom Lentil Shepherd’s Pie

Potatoes, mushrooms, lentils, vegan cheese shreds, spinach, and bread crumbs all layered up in one delicious dish – that is the beauty of this Mushroom Lentil Shepherd’s Pie. This warm and cozy bake is everything you want in a comfort meal. It’s hearty, filling, and healthy. Since this pie is basically a casserole, simply double or triple the recipe if you want to feed a large group.

7.Mushroom and Cream Cheese Flatbread

Making a flatbread and pizza from scratch may seem like a daunting task, but this Mushroom and Cream Cheese Flatbread proves it doesn’t have to be! This yeast-free and gluten-free flatbread crust comes together very easily and then is topped with cashew cream cheese, mushrooms, arugula. Enjoy the flatbread as the recipe dictates, with lemon juice, tahini, and soy sauce, or get creative with your own garnishes.

8. Choley Dingri Dopiaza: Chickpeas and Mushrooms in Caramelized Onion Curry

This dish, also called Choley Dingri Dopiaza, is a curry dish from Mughal that relies on slow-cooked onions as the base — in fact, “dopiaza” means “double onions.” Here, they’re cooked with chickpeas and woody Cremini mushrooms to make a hearty and wholesome curry. Unlike other curries, the gravy in this dish is lightly seasoned with the basics and it has delicate, sweet notes with a touch of smokiness from cumin and coriander.

9. Walnut Portobello Meatball Subs

Walnuts, Baby Bella mushrooms, savory spices, and fresh parsley are mixed with fresh bread crumbs to create the amazing meatballs in these Walnut Portobello Meatball Subs. If that wasn’t good enough, they’re stuffed into a toasted roll with balsamic-glazed vegetables. The subs come together in about 30 minutes, so they’re perfect for a weeknight, weekend, or whenever dinner.

10. Parsnip and Mushroom Pot Pies

Fall is pot pie season and this recipe for Parsnip and Mushroom Pot Pies is definitely one to try. Underneath this thermal crust, you will discover chunky, yet soft vegetables packed with nutrition which will ensure the perfect balance with every mouthful! Specifically, these pies contain panfried parsnips, mushrooms, cauliflower, turmeric, onion, garlic, and peas. Yum!

11. Creamy Mushroom Fricassee

This recipe for Creamy Mushroom Fricassee is really so versatile. You can use wine or broth or both. Use whatever veggies make your heart happy. It also works well if you add tofu or seitan chunks in when you add the mushrooms.

12.Portobello Gyros With Hemp Tzatziki

These Portobello Gyros With Hemp Tzatziki allow you to enjoy the delicious flavors of Greek cuisine, no meat or dairy required. Meaty Portobello mushrooms are tossed in Worcestershire sauce, rolled in a warm pita, and then topped with a creamy tzatziki made from hemp! Talk about a savory, umami explosion.

13. Portobello and Peanut Banh Mi

These Portobello and Peanut Banh Mi sandwiches are pure perfection. They’re stuffed with tender marinated Portobello mushroom strips, crisp vegetables and crunchy peanuts on a soft baguette smeared with vegan mayonnaise and Sriracha. There’s also a burst of flavor from fresh herbs, heat, and creaminess. These flavor-balanced sandwiches are perfect for packing for lunch.

14. Rosemary Oven-Roasted Mushrooms

These Rosemary Oven-Roasted Mushrooms are an excellent go-to side dish for parties, barbecues, or just a weeknight dinner. Cremini mushrooms are tossed in a garlicky olive oil-white wine sauce and then sprinkled with rosemary and baked in the oven. The result? Tender, savory mushrooms that would complement almost any meal!

15. Tofu Scramble and Pulled Portobello Breakfast Tacos

Tacos for breakfast is a great idea and these Tofu Scramble and Pulled Portobello Breakfast Tacos are just the ones to get you jumping out of bed. In this recipe, tofu is crumbled and transformed into a savory scramble and Portobello mushrooms are shredded and cooked in BBQ sauce until tender. Then both components are piled into soft tortillas, topped with radishes, spring onions, and a fresh squeeze of lime. Delicious!

16. Lemon Scallop Royale

Trumpet Royale is a wonderful mushroom to experiment with in the kitchen. They have a mild flavor, tremendous versatility, and even a unique beauty to them. And, as this recipe for Lemon Scallop Royale proves, paired with a creamy lemon sauce, they make a wonderful scallop alternative!

17. Portobello Burger With Caramelized Onions and Tempeh Bacon

This Portobello Burger With Caramelized Onions and Tempeh Bacon is bursting with flavor! It has a creamy radicchio slaw made with homemade avocado mayonnaise, savory Portobello mushroom, smoky tempeh bacon, and caramelized onion. A little messy, but undeniably worth it!

18. Savory Mushroom Tart

This puffy pastry Savory Mushroom Tart has a mixture of Baby Bella mushrooms sautéed in soy sauce and balsamic vinegar then sprinkled with fresh herbs. It’s flaky, warm, savory, and very shareable! Slice it up and serve as an appetizer or pair with a fresh salad.

19. Portobello Mushroom Steaks

Get out your steak knives! This juicy Portobello Mushroom Steak will satisfy your cravings and fill you up. Sauteed with onions, balsamic vinegar, mirin, and herbs it’s a compassionate alternative to eating our furry friends!

20. Hot and Hearty Mushroom Curry

This Hot and Hearty Mushroom Curry is a little sweet, nicely spicy and packed with meaty mushrooms. The all-veggie sauce is easy to make and brimming with authentic Indian flavor. This is a satisfying dish that will warm you inside and out.

When you’re craving something meaty and savory, these mushroom recipes will satisfy even the fiercest cravings.

Lead image source: Portobello Burger With Caramelized Onions and Tempeh Bacon

20 of Our Meatiest, Beefiest, and Most Savory Mushroom Recipes (2024)

FAQs

What is a good mushroom substitute for steak? ›

We'd be hard pressed to say that mushrooms can really replace a steak on the grill or under the broiler — especially if they were put side-by-side. But consider this a call to try seasoning portobello mushrooms and putting them under the broiler or on the grill instead of just between burger buns.

What is mushroom meat? ›

Shiitakes: The Smoky Flavor Enhancers

Shiitake mushrooms, native to East Asia, are renowned for their rich, umami flavor. They also have a distinct smoky note that enhances any dish they're added to. Their meaty texture makes them an ideal substitute for meat in a variety of vegan recipes, from stir-fries to soups.

Which mushroom tastes the most like meat? ›

Swap your beef for portobello steaks

The portobello mushroom crowns as the superior beef replacement due to their satisfying texture and array of flavours. This mushroom's absorbency can soak up sauces effortlessly, leaving for a fulfilling dish.

Which mushroom tastes like chicken? ›

This fried chicken-tasting mushroom is called Laetiporus sulphureus and is more commonly known as 'Chicken of the Woods. ' It can be found across Europe and North America, mainly on oak trees, but can also be found on yew, cherry, and sweet chestnut trees.

What mushroom tastes like lobster? ›

Lobster mushrooms are large, white-capped mushrooms bearing a red fungus that gives them a taste and texture similar to lobster. Learn more about how to identify, clean, and prepare these succulent mushrooms.

What mushroom tastes like shrimp? ›

The taste of Russula xerampelina is mild. This Russula is considered one of the best edible species of its genus, although the crab, or shrimp taste and smell will persist even when cooking.

What is the mushroom that looks like a steak? ›

Beefsteak fungus (Fistulina hepatica)

Which mushroom is a super food? ›

When we talk about functional mushrooms, we're not just referring to your standard grocery store variety (although they certainly have their place in a healthy diet). Research suggests that varieties like chaga, lion's mane, reishi, and cordyceps may offer health benefits beyond basic nutrition.

Which mushroom is not edible? ›

However, some mushrooms like Amanita phalloides are non-edible. Amanita phalloides are considered the most poisonous mushroom. It is also known as the death trap mushroom, as it results in life-threatening hepatorenal dysfunction when consumed. It leads to massive centrilobular necrosis and vascular degeneration.

What mushroom is a delicacy? ›

One of the most prized mushrooms, porcini mushrooms are desired for their smooth texture and aromatic, woodsy flavor. They're widely used in Italy and France and are referred to as cepes. Fresh porcini are beloved by gourmet chefs and are often sautéed and served as a side dish or added to risottos and pasta dishes.

What fungi tastes like steak? ›

Beefsteak fungus (Fistulina hepatica)

What mushroom is best for steak? ›

There are plenty of wild mushrooms to choose from, but in many cases, basic white or brown button mushrooms are all you need for a great topping. The button mushrooms have plenty of moisture that turns into a rich broth as they cook, adding to the sauce that you use for topping the steaks.

What is the best substitute for steak? ›

Here are our best recipes for satisfying veggie steak.
  • King Oyster Mushroom Steaks with Pesto and Almond Aillade. ...
  • Crispy Tofu Steaks with Ginger Vinaigrette. ...
  • Roasted Butternut Squash with Chorizo-Spiced Kale. ...
  • Sausage-Spiced Cauliflower Steaks.
Dec 19, 2022

What is the best type of mushroom for cooking? ›

Shiitake mushrooms are a versatile and affordable choice with more flavor and more health benefits than agaricus bisporus varieties. With their meaty yet buttery texture and rich, umami taste, shiitake mushrooms add depth and complexity to various dishes. Their earthy taste stands out when they are dried.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Kareem Mueller DO

Last Updated:

Views: 5793

Rating: 4.6 / 5 (66 voted)

Reviews: 89% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Kareem Mueller DO

Birthday: 1997-01-04

Address: Apt. 156 12935 Runolfsdottir Mission, Greenfort, MN 74384-6749

Phone: +16704982844747

Job: Corporate Administration Planner

Hobby: Mountain biking, Jewelry making, Stone skipping, Lacemaking, Knife making, Scrapbooking, Letterboxing

Introduction: My name is Kareem Mueller DO, I am a vivacious, super, thoughtful, excited, handsome, beautiful, combative person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.