I Tested A Ton Of Cookie Recipes To Find The Absolute Best (2024)

Posted on Sep 10, 2017

138 cookies and 10 pounds of chocolate later, I found the recipe you should be using.

by Jesse SzewczykBuzzFeed Staff

I Tested A Ton Of Cookie Recipes To Find The Absolute Best (2)

Hello, world! I'm Jesse, and I love to bake — especially chocolate chip cookies. They're simple and delicious, and their flavor takes me right back to my childhood.

I Tested A Ton Of Cookie Recipes To Find The Absolute Best (3)

Still, I know that pretty much everyone has a recipe they swear by.

NBC

So I decided to test five of the most popular. A ~chocolate chip cookie showdown~, if you will:

I Tested A Ton Of Cookie Recipes To Find The Absolute Best (4)

I tasted everything and also asked about a dozen of my coworkers to try, for maximum cookie feedback. Here are the methods and how they stacked up:

Alton Brown was up first. He swaps all-purpose flour for bread flour, which he says give the cookies "extra chewiness."

I Tested A Ton Of Cookie Recipes To Find The Absolute Best (5)

I Tested A Ton Of Cookie Recipes To Find The Absolute Best (6)

Sift it onto a paper plate and melt a ton of butter in a small pot.

Combine the melted butter and two types of sugar in a mixer and add the wet ingredients followed by the dry.

I Tested A Ton Of Cookie Recipes To Find The Absolute Best (7)

I Tested A Ton Of Cookie Recipes To Find The Absolute Best (8)

Stir in the chocolate chips and chill the dough for one hour. Bake for 15 minutes in a 350°F oven and immediately transfer onto a cooling rack.

So, is bread flour the secret ingredient for perfect cookies?

I Tested A Ton Of Cookie Recipes To Find The Absolute Best (9)

I Tested A Ton Of Cookie Recipes To Find The Absolute Best (10)

The bread flour definitely made them chewier ― like the soft-baked kind you get in a grocery store. The cookies also looked great ―perfectly round and cartoon-like with a crinkly top. They tasted exactly how a chocolate chip cookie should taste ― soft on the inside, crispy on the outside, with the perfect amount of chocolate to balance the sweetness.

Rating: 🍪🍪🍪🍪

A note from the tasting panel: “This is such a classic chocolate chip cookie. It’s soft, the right amount of sweet, and perfectly gooey.”

Get Alton Brown's recipe here.

Next up: Thomas Keller. He adds in two different types of chocolate — 55% and 72% — to really up the chocolate flavor.

I Tested A Ton Of Cookie Recipes To Find The Absolute Best (11)

I Tested A Ton Of Cookie Recipes To Find The Absolute Best (12)

Chop a bar of both and place it in a fine-mesh strainer to remove any "chocolate dust."

Beat butter and sugar in a mixer and add your wet and dry ingredients, and stir in the ~dustless~ chopped chocolate.

I Tested A Ton Of Cookie Recipes To Find The Absolute Best (13)

I Tested A Ton Of Cookie Recipes To Find The Absolute Best (14)

Bake everything as usual and let cookies cool on the sheet tray.

So were they worth the trouble of chopping two types of chocolate?

I Tested A Ton Of Cookie Recipes To Find The Absolute Best (15)

I Tested A Ton Of Cookie Recipes To Find The Absolute Best (16)

Definitely! These cookies were damn good! The two types of chocolate balanced each other out and made these cookies ridiculously indulgent. The texture was fudgy and soft — as if a sugar cookie and a brownie had a baby. The dough spread quite a bit (and it looked more like a sugar cookie than a classic chocolate chip cookie), but the flavor was out of this world.

Rating: 🍪🍪🍪🍪🍪

A note from the tasting panel: "It may look a little different than a normal chocolate chip cookie, but definitely don’t judge this cookie by its cover. I could eat a dozen of these!”

Get Thomas Keller's recipe here.

Then came Bobby Flay's recipe. His secret cookie ingredient is muscovado sugar — an unrefined sugar with a strong molasses flavor. He starts by whisking his dry ingredients in a bowl.

I Tested A Ton Of Cookie Recipes To Find The Absolute Best (17)

I Tested A Ton Of Cookie Recipes To Find The Absolute Best (18)

Beat butter and sugar in a mixer until fluffy.

Add eggs, vanilla extract, and dry ingredients in two batches.

I Tested A Ton Of Cookie Recipes To Find The Absolute Best (19)

I Tested A Ton Of Cookie Recipes To Find The Absolute Best (20)

Finish with chunks of semisweet chocolate, bake 'em, and let them rest on the hot cookie sheet for two minutes before transferring to a cooling rack.

So should you be running to the store to stock up on muscovado sugar?

I Tested A Ton Of Cookie Recipes To Find The Absolute Best (21)

I Tested A Ton Of Cookie Recipes To Find The Absolute Best (22)

Eh, don't rush. The cookies looked similar to Thomas Keller's, but they didn't have nearly as much flavor. They were super buttery, soft, and perfectly chewy, but they lacked flavor and needed more salt. The only thing I could taste was butter (which is never a bad thing), but I wanted them to have a stronger chocolate note. Looks like Bobby might have finally been beat...

Rating: 🍪🍪🍪

A note from the tasting panel: “The butter is definitely noticeable (and I love me some damn butter). It’s not too chewy, and they have the perfect bite. I loved how subtle the chocolate is — not overwhelming at all.”

Get Bobby Flay's recipe here.

Up next: ~Wild card~ Kourtney Kardashian, whose dairy-free and gluten-free chocolate chip cookies called for organic cane sugar, vegetable shortening, and lots of coconut oil.

I Tested A Ton Of Cookie Recipes To Find The Absolute Best (23)

I Tested A Ton Of Cookie Recipes To Find The Absolute Best (24)

Mix shortening, coconut oil, and sugar in a bowl.

In a separate bowl, mix coconut flour, rice flour, salt, and baking soda and add it to the sugar mixture.

I Tested A Ton Of Cookie Recipes To Find The Absolute Best (25)

I Tested A Ton Of Cookie Recipes To Find The Absolute Best (26)

Add dairy-free semisweet chocolate chips, chill the dough, then roll them into balls and bake 'em.

So was it worth the $50 I spent on all those fancy ingredients?

I Tested A Ton Of Cookie Recipes To Find The Absolute Best (27)

I Tested A Ton Of Cookie Recipes To Find The Absolute Best (28)

LOL NOPE — and from now on, let's not call these cookies (because they're not worthy of that sacred title). They were dry, sandy, and all I could taste was coconut oil. I understand that she wanted to make a ~healthier~ version of the classic (and that she isn't a trained chef), but that doesn't mean they should be SO dry that they literally exfoliate my mouth as I chew. When using coconut flour, you have to use A LOT of eggs to counteract how dry it can make things, and it seems that Kourtney may have missed that memo. But hey, she is pretty busy these days. *sips my Fit Tea*

Rating: Zero.

A note from the tasting panel: "This is not a chocolate chip cookie."

Get Kourtney Kardashian's recipe here.

And last but not least: Toll House — the ultimate childhood classic. Start by combining your dry ingredients in a bowl.

I Tested A Ton Of Cookie Recipes To Find The Absolute Best (29)

I Tested A Ton Of Cookie Recipes To Find The Absolute Best (30)

Then beat butter, sugar, and vanilla extract in a mixer until creamy.

Add eggs, flour mixture, and stir in chocolate chips and nuts. (Yep, the original recipe has nuts in it.)

I Tested A Ton Of Cookie Recipes To Find The Absolute Best (31)

I Tested A Ton Of Cookie Recipes To Find The Absolute Best (32)

Bake 'em and let them rest on the hot cookie sheet for two minutes before transferring to a cooling rack.

So were they as good as my childhood memories made them out to be?

I Tested A Ton Of Cookie Recipes To Find The Absolute Best (33)

I Tested A Ton Of Cookie Recipes To Find The Absolute Best (34)

I hate to ruin your childhood, but no ― these cookies were nothing special (the white bread of cookies, if you will). The batter didn't spread out and they ended up looking lumpy and sad. The flavor was mild and the chocolate and nuts didn't shine through. I would never turn down a Toll House cookie ― but I wouldn't recommend using the recipe either. Compared with the others, this cookie just didn't do it for me.

Rating: 🍪🍪

A note from the tasting panel: "These look like something my mother would make."

Get the classic Toll House recipe here.

SO WHO WON?

I Tested A Ton Of Cookie Recipes To Find The Absolute Best (35)

I Tested A Ton Of Cookie Recipes To Find The Absolute Best (36)

TL;DR: If you want a seriously decadent cookie that's PACKED with chocolate, go with Thomas Keller's recipe (which was honestly the most indulgent chocolate chip cookie I have ever had). If you want a classic, chewy chocolate chip cookie (that isn't as hard to make), try Alton Brown's recipe.